← Back to list

Rolling Pin Bake Shop

2935 South Fish Hatchery Road Unit 4, Fitchburg

bakery

65 · Local
Not local Local
Show more local alternatives

Ownership

Co-owners Tanya Laiter and Bill McKlight share a love of creating and both hold art degrees. The business was founded in 2002 as a family-friendly neighborhood bakery and appears to be independently owned rather than part of a chain or franchise.

75/100 high confidence

Local Sourcing

The website mentions locally harvested honey in some menu items, indicating some local sourcing. However, limited public information about overall sourcing practices makes a full assessment difficult.

50/100 medium confidence

Community Involvement

The business is a member of the Fitchburg Chamber of Commerce and receives strong local community recognition. However, specific information about sponsorships or deep nonprofit/school ties is not evident in search results.

50/100 medium confidence

Local Workforce

Rolling Pin Bake Shop is rated 4.3 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #7 of 41 restaurants in Fitchburg. Customer reviews consistently praise the bakery, suggesting quality operations, though specific wage or tenure information is unavailable.

75/100 medium confidence

Revenue Retention

As an independent bakery producing goods fresh in-house, most revenue likely stays local rather than flowing to corporate headquarters. However, the absence of specific financial data limits confidence in this assessment.

75/100 medium confidence

Local Presence

Strong local signals include business opening story (December 2002), specific Madison/Fitchburg references (Dane County Farmer's Market, Capitol Square, Hilldale Market, Agora Pavilion), direct local phone number, single-location focus, and personality-driven copy ('You dream it, we make it!'). No corporate signals detected.

75/100 high confidence
© 2026 Four Lakes Local — Madison, WI